On last Tuesday I after I got done with my school job I did my usual looking at my fellow blogs as well catch up with the recent passings of people to see who I'm surprised that have passed away. Well I was surprised that Sam 'Sudden Sam' McDowell passed away then it occurred to me that there's always someone like him that is yes he's was a fan favorite with the Indians but a pitcher that had numbers but didn't win a Cy Young Award. So it got me to think what pitchers would fall in the same category had numbers but didn't win a Cy Young award & from what I gathered there's at least one pitcher every year so I broken it down since 1956 when the first Cy Young Award was rewarded but I'll break it down by the decades.
Now the criteria for them to be on here these pitchers had long careers with numbers but didn't win the award some were considered for it but somehow someone else won it & there is alot of Hall of Fame pitchers listed as well future Hall of Fame members in my opinion & then there's a bunch of fan favorites if I don't mention a player you think deserves to be included drop it in the comments below thanks also some of these guys played in multiple decades but I will focus when they started their careers as well mentioned the other decades that they qualify for as well even if they didn't start or finish a particular decade.
But before I featured the list I will point out on my Ken Griffey Sr. Post I mentioned that someone if they had a keen eye in finding what "I Spyed" with my lil eye 2 people mentioned but 1 correctly identified the location but I figured both people deserved a prize they are Fuji & Derek. Derek identified the the location correctly so Derek send me your email address & I'll drop you an email once I receive it from you to get further information about your redemption award Fuji I'll be sending yours in a pwe later this week. Those are wondering you'll have to read the comments to fully understand why they won so congratulations to again Fuji & Derek.
Now on with the list of pitchers that were stars had numbers & lengthy careers but didn't win a Cy Young award.
1950s
Robin Roberts as well the 1960s
Frank Lary
Billy Pierce as well in the 1960s
Lew Burdette
Johnny Podres as well in the 1970s
Elroy Face as well the 1960s
Jim Kaat as well in the 1960s,1970s, & 1980s
1960s
Juan Marichal as well the 1970s
Don Sutton as well the 1970s & 1980s
Mickey Lolich as well the 1970s
Nolan Ryan as well the 1970s,1980s & 1990s
John Hiller as well the 1970s & 1980s
Phil Niekro as well in the 1970s & 1980s
Joe Coleman Jr. as well in the 1970s
Joe Niekro as well in the 1970s & 1980s
Bob Veale
Tommy John as well in the 1970s & 1980s
1970s
Paul Splitrorff as well in the 1980s
Steve Busby
Jack Morris as well in the 1980s & 1990s
JR Richard as well in the 1980s
Frank Tanana as well in the 1980s
Dave Stieb as well in the 1980s, & 1990s
Bert Blyleven as well in the 1980s & 1990s
Jim Clancy as well in the 1980s & 1990s
1980s
Tom Browning as well in the 1990s
Mark Langston as well in the 1990s
Dave Stewart as well in the 1990s
Mike Witt as well in the 1990s
Dave Righetti as well in the 1990s
Danny Jackson as well in the 1990s
Jim Abbott as well in the 1990s
Teddy Higuera
1990s
Mike Mussina as well in the 2000s
I am sure that you get the idea of these guys like I mentioned before if ya can think of others don't hesitate to mention them. As always I am reminded of what Rogers Hornsby once said about signing autographs for little kids "Any ballplayer who doesn't sign autographs for little kids ain't an American, He's a Communist."